Moving Beyond the Windsor Framework - Amendment 1

Division held on 8 September 2025. The Amendment Therefore Fell

Decision type
Simple Majority
Method
Lobby Division
Result
The Amendment Therefore Fell
Debate
Windsor Framework

The motion voted on

Motion Amendment (Private Members' Motion): Moving Beyond the Windsor Framework - Amendment 1

Leave out all after ‘ceased trade in Northern Ireland’ and insert: ‘notes that the recent Independent Review of the Windsor Framework is a missed opportunity to recognise the trade, economic and sovereignty challenges to both Northern Ireland and to the integrity of the United Kingdom as a whole; further notes that the existing safeguards within the Windsor Framework, including the Democratic Consent Mechanism, the Stormont Brake, voting against applicability motions within the Assembly, the oversight by the Windsor Framework Democratic Scrutiny Committee and the UK Government’s role in safeguarding the integrity of the United Kingdom have all failed to arrest continued divergence within the internal UK market, and further, that existing processes as introduced by HMRC and other agencies have added to the cost of doing business within Northern Ireland; is concerned that changes to sanitary and phytosanitary and other germane regulations will not be fully discussed between UK Government and the EU until 2027 with likely implementation not until 2028 and beyond; and calls on the UK Government to use the existing provisions within Article 16 of the Windsor Framework and pause all further implementation of the Windsor Framework until after completion of the UK-EU reset negotiations in 2027, rather than blindly following the faithful implementation approach that is accelerating divergence within our nation.’

The motion has not been assessed yet.

Tabled by: Dr Steve Aiken OBE, Ms Diana Armstrong, Mr Doug Beattie MC, Mr Robbie Butler

Totals

Votes by community designation, as published
DesignationAyesNoesAbstentions
Nationalist0340
Unionist3400
Other0150
Total34490

How each MLA voted

Democratic Unionist Party: 24 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Maurice BradleyAyeUnionist
Mr Phillip BrettAyeUnionist
Mr David BrooksAyeUnionist
Ms Cheryl BrownleeAyeUnionist
Mr Keith BuchananAyeUnionist
Mr Tom BuchananAyeUnionist
Mr Jonathan BuckleyAyeUnionist
Ms Joanne BuntingAyeUnionist
Mrs Pam CameronAyeUnionist
Mr Trevor ClarkeAyeUnionist
Mrs Diane DoddsAyeUnionist
Mr Stephen DunneAyeUnionist
Ms Diane ForsytheAyeUnionist
Mr Paul FrewAyeUnionist
Mr Paul GivanAyeUnionist
Mr Harry HarveyAyeUnionist
Mr William IrwinAyeUnionist
Mr Brian KingstonAyeUnionist
Mrs Emma Little-PengellyAyeUnionist
Mr Gordon LyonsAyeUnionist
Miss Michelle McIlveenAyeUnionist
Mr Peter MartinAyeUnionist
Mr Gary MiddletonAyeUnionist
Mr Alan RobinsonAyeUnionist
Independent: 1 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Ms Claire SugdenAyeUnionist
People Before Profit Alliance: 0 Aye, 1 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Gerry CarrollNoOther
Sinn Féin: 0 Aye, 27 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Dr Caoimhe ArchibaldNoNationalist
Mr Danny BakerNoNationalist
Mr Cathal BoylanNoNationalist
Miss Nicola BroganNoNationalist
Mr Pádraig DelargyNoNationalist
Mrs Linda DillonNoNationalist
Miss Jemma DolanNoNationalist
Mrs Sinéad EnnisNoNationalist
Mrs Ciara FergusonNoNationalist
Ms Aoife FinneganNoNationalist
Miss Órlaithí FlynnNoNationalist
Mr Colm GildernewNoNationalist
Miss Deirdre HargeyNoNationalist
Mr Declan KearneyNoNationalist
Mr Gerry KellyNoNationalist
Ms Liz KimminsNoNationalist
Mr Declan McAleerNoNationalist
Mr Philip McGuiganNoNationalist
Mr Maolíosa McHughNoNationalist
Mrs Cathy MasonNoNationalist
Miss Áine MurphyNoNationalist
Ms Carál Ní ChuilínNoNationalist
Mr John O'DowdNoNationalist
Ms Michelle O'NeillNoNationalist
Ms Aisling ReillyNoNationalist
Mr Pat SheehanNoNationalist
Ms Emma SheerinNoNationalist
Social Democratic and Labour Party: 0 Aye, 7 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Mark DurkanNoNationalist
Mr Daniel McCrossanNoNationalist
Mr Patsy McGloneNoNationalist
Mr Colin McGrathNoNationalist
Ms Sinéad McLaughlinNoNationalist
Mr Justin McNultyNoNationalist
Mr Matthew O'TooleNoNationalist
Traditional Unionist Voice: 1 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Timothy GastonAyeUnionist
Ulster Unionist Party: 8 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Dr Steve Aiken OBEAyeUnionist
Mr Andy Allen MBEAyeUnionist
Ms Diana ArmstrongAyeUnionist
Mr Doug Beattie MCAyeUnionist
Mr Jon BurrowsAyeUnionist
Mr Robbie ButlerAyeUnionist
Mr Mike NesbittAyeUnionist
Mr John StewartAyeUnionist

MLAs who did not vote are not listed. Download these votes (CSV)