The Irish Government’s Failure to Cooperate on Legacy Cases - Amendment 1
Division held on 19 May 2026. The Amendment Therefore Fell
- Decision type
- Simple Majority
- Method
- Lobby Division
- Result
- The Amendment Therefore Fell
- Debate
- Legacy Cases: Irish Government
Official Assembly record of this division Official Report of the debate
The motion voted on
Motion Amendment (Private Members' Motion): The Irish Government’s Failure to Cooperate on Legacy Cases - Amendment 1
Leave out all after ‘Secretary of State for Northern Ireland’ and insert: ‘continued to advance the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill under direct political pressure from the Irish Government; further believes the UK Government should consider legal action against the Irish Government for failing to conduct an investigation under Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights, into those UK citizens who were abducted in Northern Ireland, taken across the Irish border and murdered; affirms that that the Irish Government should lift their decades-long embargo on providing answers to victims of terrorism throughout the UK; believes that those police officers, members of the military and security services who acted with professionalism and within the law deserve to be protected from vexatious or repeated investigations where there is no new, compelling and credible evidence; welcomes the UK Supreme Court judgment in the Dillon case which found that the Windsor Framework was inappropriately used to strike down provisions of the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act; calls on the UK Government to take steps to substantially amend the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill to ensure it has the confidence of victims, survivors and the public, including those who served during Operation Banner; and further calls on the First Minister and deputy First Minister to write to the UK Government and the Irish Government to request they outline how they intend to meet their legacy commitments.’
The motion has not been assessed yet.
Tabled by: Mr Doug Beattie MC, Mr Jon Burrows
Totals
| Designation | Ayes | Noes | Abstentions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nationalist | 0 | 29 | 0 |
| Unionist | 26 | 0 | 0 |
| Other | 0 | 14 | 0 |
| Total | 26 | 43 | 0 |
How each MLA voted
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr John Blair | No | Other |
| Ms Paula Bradshaw | No | Other |
| Mr Stewart Dickson | No | Other |
| Mr Danny Donnelly | No | Other |
| Ms Connie Egan | No | Other |
| Mrs Michelle Guy | No | Other |
| Mr David Honeyford | No | Other |
| Mrs Naomi Long | No | Other |
| Miss Nuala McAllister | No | Other |
| Mr Peter McReynolds | No | Other |
| Mr Nick Mathison | No | Other |
| Ms Sian Mulholland | No | Other |
| Ms Kate Nicholl | No | Other |
| Mr Eóin Tennyson | No | Other |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Maurice Bradley | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Phillip Brett | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr David Brooks | Aye | Unionist |
| Ms Cheryl Brownlee | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Keith Buchanan | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Jonathan Buckley | Aye | Unionist |
| Ms Joanne Bunting | Aye | Unionist |
| Mrs Pam Cameron | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Trevor Clarke | Aye | Unionist |
| Mrs Diane Dodds | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Stephen Dunne | Aye | Unionist |
| Mrs Deborah Erskine | Aye | Unionist |
| Ms Diane Forsythe | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Paul Frew | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Harry Harvey | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Brian Kingston | Aye | Unionist |
| Mrs Emma Little-Pengelly | Aye | Unionist |
| Miss Michelle McIlveen | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Peter Martin | Aye | Unionist |
| Mrs Julie Middleton | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Alan Robinson | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Gareth Wilson | Aye | Unionist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Danny Baker | No | Nationalist |
| Miss Nicola Brogan | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Pádraig Delargy | No | Nationalist |
| Mrs Linda Dillon | No | Nationalist |
| Miss Jemma Dolan | No | Nationalist |
| Mrs Sinéad Ennis | No | Nationalist |
| Mrs Ciara Ferguson | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Aoife Finnegan | No | Nationalist |
| Miss Órlaithí Flynn | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Colm Gildernew | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Declan Kearney | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Gerry Kelly | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Liz Kimmins | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Declan McAleer | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Philip McGuigan | No | Nationalist |
| Mrs Cathy Mason | No | Nationalist |
| Miss Áine Murphy | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Carál Ní Chuilín | No | Nationalist |
| Mr John O'Dowd | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Michelle O'Neill | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Aisling Reilly | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Emma Sheerin | No | Nationalist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Mark Durkan | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Cara Hunter | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Patsy McGlone | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Colin McGrath | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Sinéad McLaughlin | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Justin McNulty | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Matthew O'Toole | No | Nationalist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Timothy Gaston | Aye | Unionist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Doug Beattie MC | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Robbie Butler | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Alan Chambers | Aye | Unionist |
MLAs who did not vote are not listed. Download these votes (CSV)