Budgetary Pressures - Amendment 2

Division held on 10 September 2024. The Amendment Was Therefore Agreed

Decision type
Simple Majority
Method
Lobby Division
Result
The Amendment Was Therefore Agreed
Debate
Budgetary Pressures

The motion voted on

Motion Amendment (Private Members' Motion): Budgetary Pressures - Amendment 2

Leave out all after the first ‘relative need;’ and insert: ‘agrees that, while the interim Fiscal Framework agreed with the UK Government was an important first step, the proposed 124 per cent relative need factor will, as things stand, only apply to future Barnett consequentials and cannot remedy the damage caused by core funding for Northern Ireland dropping below need, prior to the restoration of devolution in February 2024; stresses that this will have a significant, adverse and recurrent impact on the scale of the Northern Ireland block grant and therefore the delivery of vital frontline services; further notes that the proposed 124 per cent relative need factor does not adequately reflect policing and justice need in Northern Ireland and the disproportionate squeeze on the justice budget; believes that a baselined fiscal floor, set at a level greater than 124 per cent, should be delivered without further delay; calls on the Minister of Finance to publish the Executive Sustainability Plan, including steps to tackle inefficiencies and duplication, which leaves the Executive with less to invest in public services each year; and further calls on the UK Government to depart from its austerity policy by agreeing a new, long-term financial settlement with the Executive, reviewing the fiscal rules and pursuing a progressive taxation system.’

The motion has not been assessed yet.

Tabled by: Ms Diane Forsythe, Mr Paul Frew

Totals

Votes by community designation, as published
DesignationAyesNoesAbstentions
Nationalist2170
Unionist2900
Other0170
Total50240

How each MLA voted

Democratic Unionist Party: 20 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Maurice BradleyAyeUnionist
Mr Phillip BrettAyeUnionist
Mr David BrooksAyeUnionist
Ms Cheryl BrownleeAyeUnionist
Mr Keith BuchananAyeUnionist
Mr Tom BuchananAyeUnionist
Mr Jonathan BuckleyAyeUnionist
Ms Joanne BuntingAyeUnionist
Mr Trevor ClarkeAyeUnionist
Mrs Diane DoddsAyeUnionist
Mr Stephen DunneAyeUnionist
Mrs Deborah ErskineAyeUnionist
Ms Diane ForsytheAyeUnionist
Mr Paul FrewAyeUnionist
Mr Harry HarveyAyeUnionist
Mr William IrwinAyeUnionist
Mr Brian KingstonAyeUnionist
Miss Michelle McIlveenAyeUnionist
Mr Peter MartinAyeUnionist
Mr Alan RobinsonAyeUnionist
People Before Profit Alliance: 0 Aye, 1 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Gerry CarrollNoOther
Sinn Féin: 21 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Dr Caoimhe ArchibaldAyeNationalist
Mr Danny BakerAyeNationalist
Mr Cathal BoylanAyeNationalist
Mrs Linda DillonAyeNationalist
Miss Jemma DolanAyeNationalist
Mrs Sinéad EnnisAyeNationalist
Mrs Ciara FergusonAyeNationalist
Miss Órlaithí FlynnAyeNationalist
Mr Colm GildernewAyeNationalist
Miss Deirdre HargeyAyeNationalist
Mr Declan KearneyAyeNationalist
Mr Gerry KellyAyeNationalist
Ms Liz KimminsAyeNationalist
Mr Declan McAleerAyeNationalist
Mr Philip McGuiganAyeNationalist
Mr Maolíosa McHughAyeNationalist
Mrs Cathy MasonAyeNationalist
Miss Áine MurphyAyeNationalist
Mr John O'DowdAyeNationalist
Mr Pat SheehanAyeNationalist
Ms Emma SheerinAyeNationalist
Social Democratic and Labour Party: 0 Aye, 7 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Mark DurkanNoNationalist
Ms Cara HunterNoNationalist
Mr Patsy McGloneNoNationalist
Mr Colin McGrathNoNationalist
Ms Sinéad McLaughlinNoNationalist
Mr Justin McNultyNoNationalist
Mr Matthew O'TooleNoNationalist
Traditional Unionist Voice: 1 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Mr Timothy GastonAyeUnionist
Ulster Unionist Party: 8 Aye, 0 No
MLAVoteDesignation
Dr Steve Aiken OBEAyeUnionist
Mr Andy Allen MBEAyeUnionist
Mr Doug Beattie MCAyeUnionist
Mr Robbie ButlerAyeUnionist
Mr Alan ChambersAyeUnionist
Mr Colin CrawfordAyeUnionist
Lord ElliottAyeUnionist
Mr John StewartAyeUnionist

MLAs who did not vote are not listed. Download these votes (CSV)