Budgetary Pressures - Amendment 2
Division held on 10 September 2024. The Amendment Was Therefore Agreed
- Decision type
- Simple Majority
- Method
- Lobby Division
- Result
- The Amendment Was Therefore Agreed
- Debate
- Budgetary Pressures
Official Assembly record of this division Official Report of the debate
The motion voted on
Motion Amendment (Private Members' Motion): Budgetary Pressures - Amendment 2
Leave out all after the first ‘relative need;’ and insert: ‘agrees that, while the interim Fiscal Framework agreed with the UK Government was an important first step, the proposed 124 per cent relative need factor will, as things stand, only apply to future Barnett consequentials and cannot remedy the damage caused by core funding for Northern Ireland dropping below need, prior to the restoration of devolution in February 2024; stresses that this will have a significant, adverse and recurrent impact on the scale of the Northern Ireland block grant and therefore the delivery of vital frontline services; further notes that the proposed 124 per cent relative need factor does not adequately reflect policing and justice need in Northern Ireland and the disproportionate squeeze on the justice budget; believes that a baselined fiscal floor, set at a level greater than 124 per cent, should be delivered without further delay; calls on the Minister of Finance to publish the Executive Sustainability Plan, including steps to tackle inefficiencies and duplication, which leaves the Executive with less to invest in public services each year; and further calls on the UK Government to depart from its austerity policy by agreeing a new, long-term financial settlement with the Executive, reviewing the fiscal rules and pursuing a progressive taxation system.’
The motion has not been assessed yet.
Tabled by: Ms Diane Forsythe, Mr Paul Frew
Totals
| Designation | Ayes | Noes | Abstentions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nationalist | 21 | 7 | 0 |
| Unionist | 29 | 0 | 0 |
| Other | 0 | 17 | 0 |
| Total | 50 | 24 | 0 |
How each MLA voted
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Ms Kellie Armstrong | No | Other |
| Mr John Blair | No | Other |
| Ms Paula Bradshaw | No | Other |
| Mr Stewart Dickson | No | Other |
| Mr Danny Donnelly | No | Other |
| Mrs Michelle Guy | No | Other |
| Mr David Honeyford | No | Other |
| Mrs Naomi Long | No | Other |
| Miss Nuala McAllister | No | Other |
| Mr Andrew McMurray | No | Other |
| Mr Peter McReynolds | No | Other |
| Mr Nick Mathison | No | Other |
| Mr Andrew Muir | No | Other |
| Ms Sian Mulholland | No | Other |
| Ms Kate Nicholl | No | Other |
| Mr Eóin Tennyson | No | Other |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Maurice Bradley | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Phillip Brett | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr David Brooks | Aye | Unionist |
| Ms Cheryl Brownlee | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Keith Buchanan | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Tom Buchanan | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Jonathan Buckley | Aye | Unionist |
| Ms Joanne Bunting | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Trevor Clarke | Aye | Unionist |
| Mrs Diane Dodds | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Stephen Dunne | Aye | Unionist |
| Mrs Deborah Erskine | Aye | Unionist |
| Ms Diane Forsythe | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Paul Frew | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Harry Harvey | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr William Irwin | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Brian Kingston | Aye | Unionist |
| Miss Michelle McIlveen | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Peter Martin | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Alan Robinson | Aye | Unionist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Gerry Carroll | No | Other |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Dr Caoimhe Archibald | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Danny Baker | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Cathal Boylan | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mrs Linda Dillon | Aye | Nationalist |
| Miss Jemma Dolan | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mrs Sinéad Ennis | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mrs Ciara Ferguson | Aye | Nationalist |
| Miss Órlaithí Flynn | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Colm Gildernew | Aye | Nationalist |
| Miss Deirdre Hargey | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Declan Kearney | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Gerry Kelly | Aye | Nationalist |
| Ms Liz Kimmins | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Declan McAleer | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Philip McGuigan | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Maolíosa McHugh | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mrs Cathy Mason | Aye | Nationalist |
| Miss Áine Murphy | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr John O'Dowd | Aye | Nationalist |
| Mr Pat Sheehan | Aye | Nationalist |
| Ms Emma Sheerin | Aye | Nationalist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Mark Durkan | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Cara Hunter | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Patsy McGlone | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Colin McGrath | No | Nationalist |
| Ms Sinéad McLaughlin | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Justin McNulty | No | Nationalist |
| Mr Matthew O'Toole | No | Nationalist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Mr Timothy Gaston | Aye | Unionist |
| MLA | Vote | Designation |
|---|---|---|
| Dr Steve Aiken OBE | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Andy Allen MBE | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Doug Beattie MC | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Robbie Butler | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Alan Chambers | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr Colin Crawford | Aye | Unionist |
| Lord Elliott | Aye | Unionist |
| Mr John Stewart | Aye | Unionist |
MLAs who did not vote are not listed. Download these votes (CSV)